Private PPO vs. COBRA Coverage
The alternative
COBRA continuation
- Keep the exact same plan, doctors and deductible progress
- No health questions, so pre-existing conditions aren't an issue
- You pay 100% of the premium plus up to 2% admin, often $700–$2,000+/mo
- Usually lasts up to 18 months, then you need a new plan anyway
- 60-day election window, and coverage can be applied retroactively
With Clear Choice Health Plans
Private PPO coverage
- Often costs a fraction of a COBRA premium for healthy applicants
- Broad PPO networks that frequently include the doctors you already see
- Not tied to a former employer or an 18-month clock
- Apply any time, with a start date that can line up with your last day
- Underwritten, so health history affects eligibility and price
- Monthly costCOBRA: Full employer premium + up to 2%Private PPO: Priced to you, often far lower
- Length of coverageCOBRA: Typically up to 18 monthsPrivate PPO: Renewable, not time-limited by COBRA rules
- Health questionsCOBRA: NonePrivate PPO: Yes, underwritten
- Same doctorsCOBRA: Yes, identical planPrivate PPO: Often, confirm in network
- Deductible progressCOBRA: Carries overPrivate PPO: Starts fresh
- Family membersCOBRA: Same people as beforePrivate PPO: Choose who's covered
- Tied to old employerCOBRA: YesPrivate PPO: No
When is COBRA the smarter move?
If you're in the middle of treatment, have already met a big deductible this year, or have health conditions that would make private underwriting difficult, COBRA's continuity can be worth the price.
How do I avoid a gap if I skip COBRA?
Apply for a private plan before your employer coverage ends so the new plan starts the day after. You also have a 60-day COBRA election window, which can act as a safety net while your application is reviewed.
Can I compare my COBRA letter with private options?
Yes, and it's one of the most useful calls we have. Share your COBRA premium with your advisor and they'll show you what private options look like next to it.
COBRA is best for
- People mid-treatment who need zero disruption
- Anyone who has already met most of this year's deductible
- People whose health history makes underwriting difficult
A private PPO is best for
- Healthy people facing a COBRA bill of $700+ a month
- Families who want coverage that isn't tied to a former employer
- Anyone who wants a long-term plan rather than an 18-month bridge
The plain-language verdict
COBRA buys you continuity at full price. If continuity matters most, keep it. If cost matters most and you're in good health, a private PPO often gives you a similar network for far less.